Why are car insurance claims rejected in the UK?
Over 20% of motor insurance claims in the UK are rejected, leaving more than 1.2 million drivers each year to cover repair and third-party costs themselves.
A claim rejection simply means your insurer refuses to pay out under the terms of your policy. It could be a complete refusal, where nothing is paid, or a partial rejection, where only certain parts of your claim are refused. Either way, the financial consequences can be serious, with unfunded liabilities now exceeding £1.2 billion annually.
The most common reasons are rarely dramatic. They include failing to disclose important details when you applied for cover, using your car for purposes outside your policy (such as commuting on a social-only policy), or driving a vehicle that wasn’t roadworthy at the time of the accident. Late reporting and policy-specific exclusions also account for a significant share, while illegal acts like drink or drug driving will almost always void a claim.
This article will break down the most frequent causes of rejection, explain why they happen, and show you how to reduce the risk of being caught out.
What are the most common seasons for car insurance claim rejection?
The most common reasons for claim rejection are non-disclosure, incorrect use of the vehicle, lack of roadworthiness, late reporting, policy exclusions, and illegal behaviour.
Industry data from 2025 shows that more than one in five UK motor insurance claims are turned down, with specific causes driving the majority of refusals. Non-disclosure or misrepresentation is the single biggest factor, responsible for around 35% of rejections. This includes failing to declare previous accidents, convictions, or vehicle modifications—mistakes that insurers see as misrepresenting the risk.
Incorrect vehicle use accounts for 22% of denials. A classic example is taking out a “social and domestic” policy but then using the car for commuting or business purposes. From an insurer’s perspective, this is a breach of contract, even if the driver thought the difference was minor.
Another 18% of claims are refused because the vehicle was not roadworthy at the time of the accident. Bald tyres, an expired MOT, or faulty brakes give insurers grounds to decline cover. Late notification is also significant: around 10% of rejections occur because drivers reported incidents too slowly. Policy exclusions, such as driving outside covered territories, explain another 8%. The remaining 7% involve serious breaches, including drink or drug driving and fraudulent claims.
What these figures highlight is that most claim rejections aren’t down to insurers being unreasonable, but to issues that could have been avoided with clearer disclosure, accurate policy selection, and basic compliance with road safety and reporting obligations.
Looking to compare car insurance? Get your quote today!
Get QuotesHow does non-disclosure lead to claim denial?
Non-disclosure is the leading cause of claim rejections in the UK, responsible for 35% of refusals, often because drivers fail to disclose accidents, convictions, or modifications.
When you apply for or renew insurance, you’re legally required to provide accurate information. This includes your driving history, previous claims, penalty points, and any changes to your vehicle. If you omit or misstate these details, insurers view it as misrepresentation of the risk they agreed to cover.
Sometimes non-disclosure is deliberate, such as “fronting,” where a parent insures a car in their name but lists their child as a secondary driver to save money. In other cases, it’s unintentional. Many motorists don’t realise that small modifications like tinted windows, alloy wheels, or aftermarket spoilers need to be declared. Yet one in six rejected claims is linked directly to undeclared modifications.
The consequences can be severe. Even if the accident wasn’t your fault, an insurer can void your policy entirely if it finds evidence of non-disclosure. That means covering repair costs, medical expenses, and third-party claims out of your own pocket. In some cases, the liability can run into tens of thousands of pounds.
Non-disclosure doesn’t always mean dishonesty. But insurers apply the rules strictly, and courts back their right to do so. The safest approach is complete transparency, even about minor details you don’t think are relevant. Better a slightly higher premium than a rejected claim when you need cover most.
Do incorrect vehicle use or policy breaches cause rejections?
Yes. Around 22% of rejected claims are due to incorrect vehicle use, such as using a car insured for social use to commute or carry out business.
Insurers categorise car use in specific ways: social, social and commuting, or business use. If you only declare social use but then drive to work daily, you’re technically outside the cover you paid for. In practice, this is one of the most common traps drivers fall into, and insurers treat it as a breach of contract.
Other policy breaches include driving abroad without arranging extended cover, using the car for ride-hailing or deliveries without commercial insurance, or allowing someone not listed on the policy to drive. Even if the driver thought they were “just popping to work” or “helping a friend,” insurers often take a strict view.
The financial impact can be heavy. A collision on the way to work could leave you facing thousands in repair costs, or even larger third-party liability claims, all because the policy was not the right type. The Financial Conduct Authority has highlighted a growing number of disputes linked to claims for events not covered under purchased policies.
The lesson is simple: match your policy to your real usage. Cutting corners on cover may save a little on premiums, but it risks a complete rejection when you need the protection most.
Why does vehicle roadworthiness affect claims?
A car that isn’t roadworthy at the time of an accident is one of the most common reasons for claim rejection, accounting for 18% of denials.
UK law requires vehicles to be safe and legal to drive, with valid MOTs, tyres above the minimum tread depth, and no serious mechanical faults. If an insurer discovers that your car failed these basic standards at the time of a claim, it can refuse to pay.
For example, if you’re involved in a collision while driving on bald tyres or with defective brakes, the insurer may argue that the accident was partly due to poor maintenance. Even if the fault lay with another driver, the insurer still has grounds to decline your claim because you didn’t meet the policy requirement of keeping the car in a roadworthy condition.
The financial consequences can be steep. Repair bills frequently exceed £1,000, and if the claim also involves third-party injury or property damage, the costs can escalate into tens of thousands of pounds. That burden then falls entirely on the driver.
A simple oversight such as letting an MOT expire can have the same effect. While many motorists assume insurance will still protect them, in reality insurers often use expired certification as evidence that the vehicle wasn’t fit to be on the road.
Maintaining your car is not just a legal duty, it’s a condition of your insurance. Neglect it, and you risk turning a minor accident into a major financial setback.
What happens if you report a claim late?
Failing to notify your insurer promptly is a common reason for rejection, with around 10% of UK claims denied because they were reported too late.
Most policies require you to report an accident within 24 to 48 hours, even if you don’t plan to claim. This gives the insurer the opportunity to investigate quickly while evidence and witness accounts are still fresh. If you wait weeks or months, the delay can undermine your credibility and make it harder for the insurer to validate your version of events.
Late reporting doesn’t always mean dishonesty. Sometimes injuries like whiplash only become apparent days later, or drivers hope to resolve matters privately before involving insurers. But from the insurer’s perspective, any delay is a red flag. They may argue that the damage could have occurred after the alleged accident, or that medical symptoms are less reliable when reported late.
The result can be a partial or complete denial of cover. For example, an insurer may pay for vehicle repairs but refuse compensation for personal injury if medical evidence wasn’t supplied in time. In worse cases, the entire claim is rejected, leaving the driver to pay both their own repair costs and third-party expenses.
The message is clear: even if you’re uncertain about claiming, always notify your insurer straight away. Doing so preserves your rights and avoids falling foul of a technicality that could cost thousands.
Do policy exclusions and illegal behaviour lead to claim rejection?
Yes. Policy exclusions and illegal behaviour account for around 15% of rejected claims, covering situations that fall outside the scope of cover or involve unlawful activity.
Policy exclusions are written into the terms of every contract. They vary by insurer but often include driving outside covered territories, using the car for hire and reward without appropriate insurance, or allowing someone not authorised to drive. Around 8% of UK rejections stem from these gaps, where drivers assumed they were covered but weren’t.
Illegal behaviour makes matters worse. Roughly 7% of denials are linked to drink or drug driving, uninsured use, or attempted fraud. In such cases, not only is the claim refused, but drivers may face criminal prosecution, fines, points, or disqualification. Convictions also make future insurance more expensive or difficult to obtain.
The FCA has reported a rise in rejections caused by drivers making claims for events not included in the policy they purchased. A common example is submitting a claim for accidental damage when the driver only had third-party cover. In these cases, rejection is inevitable because the policy never included that benefit.
The key point is that insurers aren’t required to cover circumstances that were never part of the agreement, and they will not pay where the driver has broken the law. Both exclusions and illegal acts leave claimants without financial support and, in many cases, facing additional legal consequences.
How can you avoid car insurance claim rejection?
You can reduce the risk of claim rejection by being honest when applying, keeping your car roadworthy, and reporting incidents without delay.
Most rejections are avoidable. Non-disclosure is the biggest cause, accounting for 35% of denials. That means failing to declare past accidents, convictions, or even minor modifications like tinted windows. While these details may seem unimportant, insurers consider them material information. If in doubt, declare it.
Incorrect use is another trap. If you commute, make sure your policy includes commuting cover. If you occasionally use your car for business, select a policy that reflects that. Cutting corners here might save a few pounds in premiums, but it risks leaving you uninsured when you need help most.
Maintenance matters too. Nearly one in five denials arises from unroadworthy vehicles—expired MOTs, unsafe tyres, or mechanical failures. Keeping your vehicle in legal condition is both a safety issue and a core requirement of your policy.
Finally, timing is critical. Report accidents to your insurer immediately, even if you don’t yet know whether you’ll claim. Delays of even a few days can weaken your position and give insurers grounds to reject.
Quick tips to prevent rejection:
- Always disclose past accidents, convictions, and modifications
- Choose the correct policy type for how you actually drive
- Keep your MOT and servicing up to date
- Notify your insurer promptly after an incident
These simple steps won’t eliminate every risk, but they dramatically lower your chances of joining the one in five UK drivers whose claims are turned away.
Final thoughts
More than one in five car insurance claims in the UK are rejected, but most rejections stem from avoidable mistakes.
Non-disclosure, incorrect vehicle use, poor roadworthiness, and late reporting account for the majority of denials. Policy exclusions and illegal behaviour also feature prominently, leaving drivers without financial support and, in some cases, facing legal action. Collectively, these rejections cost motorists more than £1.2 billion each year.
The good news is that careful preparation makes a difference. Declaring all relevant details, keeping your vehicle in legal condition, and notifying your insurer promptly are simple steps that significantly reduce the risk of a refusal. Reading your policy closely and choosing the right cover type for your circumstances is equally important.
Claim rejection can feel like insurers are being unfair, but in reality most refusals are based on clear breaches of policy terms or legal obligations. By being transparent and proactive, you protect yourself against unnecessary financial exposure and improve your chances of a smooth claims process when you need it most.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Non-disclosure or misrepresentation is the most common cause, responsible for about 35% of UK claim denials.
Yes. Insurers access databases such as the Claims and Underwriting Exchange (CUE) to verify accident and claims history.
If you don’t declare them, yes. Undeclared modifications like tinted windows or alloy wheels are a common reason for rejection.
Yes. Many policies require incidents to be reported within 24–48 hours. Delays may result in partial or full denial.
Potentially. If your vehicle is unroadworthy or lacks a valid MOT, insurers often refuse to cover accident claims.
Exclusions vary but often include driving abroad without cover, using the vehicle for business when not insured, or unauthorised drivers.
Yes. Claims involving drink or drug driving are usually rejected, and drivers may also face legal penalties and higher future premiums.
They use fraud detection systems, cross-checks with national databases, and investigate inconsistencies in evidence or statements.